Spiral stairs, no sprinklers may have contributed to deadly Japan fire

Spiral stairs, no sprinklers may have contributed to deadly Japan fire

By Elaine Lies, Kiyoshi Takenaka



Firefighters conduct an investigation at the Kyoto Animation building which was torched by arson attack, in Kyoto, Japan, July 19, 2019. REUTERS/Kim Kyung-Hoon


TOKYO (Reuters) - The fire that tore through a building in Japan killing 33 people may have spread so fast not only because it was fueled by petrol but because it was funneled up a spiral staircase and there were no sprinklers to douse it, experts said on Friday.


A man shouting “die” and screaming accusations of plagiarism sloshed what appeared to be petrol in the three-storey Kyoto Animation building on Thursday before setting it ablaze.

That alone could have been enough to make it impossible for victims to escape, architects said.


But an open, three-storey spiral staircase inside the building created an especially deadly environment for fire.


“The structure of the building was that it had one spiral staircase penetrating through three floors acting as a chimney, the most effective way of starting a fire,” said Momoko Higuchi, a Tokyo-based architect.


“Because the fire was with petrol, the effect was like a bomb. Most died of smoke.”


The building did not have sprinklers, nor indoor fire hydrants, but it did not have to have them under Japan’s fire code, a Kyoto Fire Department official said.


An inspection of the building in October had found no fire safety problems, he said.


Buildings usually fall into different categories depending on size, said Shinichi Sugawara, a professor emeritus at Tokyo University of Science.


While fire shutters are often required around structures like spiral staircases, to enclose then to prevent the spread of fire, Sugawara said he had heard that they were not needed in this case.


Some Japanese media has said that was because of the building’s relatively small floor space.


“I personally think that all places like that should have shutters, and all buildings should have sprinklers, regardless of size,” he said.


But the most lethal factor may simply have been the petrol.


“Petrol vaporizes quickly and really burns fast, and given the kind of business it was, there may have been a lot of papers and things lying around,” Sugawara added.


“Then the smoke would rise up the stairs.”



-- © Copyright Reuters 2019-07-19
Follow Thaivisa on LINE for breaking Thailand news and visa info
latest news from World

Senior UK Conservative lawmaker says he could not back Corbyn-led government FILE PHOTO: British Conservative MP Oliver Letwin listens in the Parliament during a debate on alternatives to Prime Minister Theresa May's Brexit Deal, in London, Britain April 3, 2019, in this screen grab taken from...


Fiji PM accuses Australia's Morrison of 'insulting' Pacific island nationsBy Lidia Kelly FILE PHOTO: Prime Minister of Fiji and COP 23 President Frank Bainimarama speaks during the COP24 UN Climate Change Conference 2018 in Katowice, Poland December 3, 2018. REUTERS/Kacper Pempel MELBOURNE...


Charity ship says migrants' safety at risk; minors allowed to disembarkBy Guglielmo Mangiapane and Joan Faus Spanish migrant rescue ship Open Arms lies anchored close to the Italian shore in Lampedusa, Italy August 17, 2019. REUTERS/Guglielmo Mangiapane LAMPEDUSA/BARCELONA (Reuters) - A charity...


Sudanese army and civilians seal interim power-sharing dealBy Khalid Abdelaziz Sudan's Head of Transitional Military Council, Lieutenant General Abdel Fattah Al-Burhan, and Sudan's opposition alliance coalition's leader Ahmad al-Rabiah, celebrate the signing of the power sharing deal, that paves...